[HGPI Policy Column] No. 18 – From the Dementia Policy Team – Considering the Importance of Global Efforts from Multi-Stakeholders for Issues in Dementia in Terms of Dementia Risk Factors
– The latest Lancet Commission report presented by Professor Gill Livingston of University College, London (UCL) added three new potentially modifiable risk factors for dementia to the nine factors described in a previous report from 2017. They are traumatic brain injury, excessive alcohol consumption, and air pollution.
– People in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC) face more risk factors and are at greater risk of dementia than people in high-income countries.
– Dementia risk factors are rooted in many domains and exist throughout the life course. Furthermore, risk factors vary among countries. Eliminating risk factors will require efforts from multi-stakeholders on a global scale.
Our previous dementia column discussed recommendations from the Ministry of Internal Affairs and Communications (MIC) on dementia policy based on the results of a third-party evaluation survey that was presented on May 12, 2020 which examined Initial-phase Intensive Support Teams for Dementia and medical centers for dementia. The authority to decide policy rests with the legislative branch, or the Diet, but members of civil society are responsible for shouldering a portion of that burden by electing representatives in the policy decision making process. Therefore, we concluded that members of civil society must take action to improve policy.
As the lives of many depend on healthcare policy, discussions in this field place a strong emphasis on scientific evidence. In this column, we would like to discuss a recent report published in The Lancet, which is a renowned international journal of medical science and is highly-trusted in a field that values scientific evidence.
The Three New Potentially Modifiable Risk Factors
In a report published in The Lancet in 2017, UCL’s Professor Gill Livingston and her team identified nine potentially modifiable risk factors for dementia. That report then calculated the population attributable fraction (PAF)*1 for those nine factors. The PAF for the nine risk factors was 35% (Figure 1), meaning that 35% of the population would not have developed dementia had all nine risk factors been absent. To draw that conclusion, the report conducted a comprehensive analysis of multiple studies using systematic reviews and meta-analyses.
Professor Gill Livingston’s latest report is entitled, “Dementia prevention, intervention, and care: 2020 report of the Lancet Commission,” and was published in the July 30, 2020 edition of The Lancet. It identified three new potentially modifiable risk factors, which were traumatic brain injury, excessive alcohol consumption, and air pollution, making a total of twelve risk factors with a total PAF of 40% (Figure 2).
In addition to injuries sustained in vehicular accidents involving cars, motorcycles, and bicycles and injuries sustained in battle, traumatic brain injuries can also occur in various sports such as boxing and horseback riding.
The report defined “excessive alcohol consumption” as 21 units per week or 3 units daily. One unit contains 8 g of pure alcohol, so in terms of pure alcohol intake, those standards would equate to 168 g per week or 24 g per day. However, Health Japan 21 (the second term) states that the daily amount of pure alcohol consumption associated with increased risk of lifestyle diseases is 40 g or more for men and 20 g or more for women, so the definition of “excessive alcohol consumption” in terms of pure alcohol intake used in the report was more stringent than health standards in Japan.
Air pollution generally increases the risk of non-communicable diseases. The report analyzed air pollution and discovered that exposure to pollutants such as PM2.5, nitrogen dioxide, and carbon monoxide from sources such as traffic exhaust and residential wood burning were associated with increased dementia risk.
People in Low- and Middle-Income Countries Face Greater Risk
The report also concluded that dementia risk is higher in LMIC compared to high-income countries. Calculating PAF (Figure 1) using the nine potentially modifiable risk factors described in the 2017 report by country results in a PAF of 40% for China, a PAF of 41% for India, and a PAF of 56% for Latin America, and these numbers may be even higher depending on which estimates of risk factor frequency are used. It is likely that the situations in such countries will improve if measures are implemented to address poor access to education, causes and management of high blood pressure, causes and treatment of hearing loss, and socioeconomic and commercial factors that cause obesity.
The Significance of Global Efforts for Dementia by Multi-stakeholders
This column discussed dementia risk factors identified in a recent report published in the medical journal The Lancet. As the report showed us, potentially modifiable risk factors for dementia exist across many domains. In addition to healthcare, the factors are related to education and all fields of industry, and they are present throughout the life course. Instead of an approach from a specific field that targets a specific age group, reducing or eliminating these risk factors will require understanding of dementia from all of society. Also, people in LMIC are at greater risk, so cooperation from international society will be absolutely essential to find solutions.
We must not forget that 60% of risk factors were “Unknown,” so more than anything, it is necessary for each individual, every family, and all of society to be prepared to provide mutual support so that everyone can continue living as well as possible even if someone develops dementia.
*1 Population Attributable Fraction (PAF):
“Attributable” refers to attributable risk, which describes the degree to which chances of developing a certain disease increase after exposure to a certain risk factor. PAF is the ratio of people who develop the disease among a population that has been exposed to a certain risk factor to indicate the real-world effects of exposure. In other words, PAF allows us to estimate the ratio of people who would not have developed a disease had they not been exposed to a certain risk factor.
MHLW, “Health Japan 21.”
Japan Epidemiological Association. “Attributable Risk and Attributable Risk Ratios.”
Livingston et al, 2020. “Dementia prevention, intervention, and care: 2020 report of the Lancet Commission.” The Lancet, 396, 413-446.
About the author
Shunichiro Kurita (HGPI Manager; Steering Committee Member, Designing for Dementia Hub)
Top Research & Recommendations Posts
- [Research Report] Survey of Japanese Physicians Regarding Climate Change and Health (December 3, 2023)
- [Research Paper] “Rethinking Japan’s Health System Sustainability Under the Planetary Health Framework” Published in Health Systems & Reform (November 21, 2023)
- [Announcement] HGPI Joins Call for “Global Health and Medical Community Unite To Demand End Fossil Fuel Dependency at COP28” (November 1, 2023)
- [Announcement] HGPI Endorsed “For the Health of People and Planet: Priorities for a Healthy COP28” (November 30, 2023)
- [Research Report] The Public Opinion Survey on Child-Rearing in Modern Japan (Final Report) (March 4, 2022)
- [Policy Recommendations] Coming Together to Protect and Foster: Promoting Innovative and Sustainable Planetary Health in the Asia-Pacific Region to Build Resilient Health Systems (November 29, 2023)
- [Research Report] Building a Mental Health Program for Children and Measuring its Effectiveness (June 16, 2022）
- [Activity Report] HGPI Submits Requests for the G7 Hiroshima Summit to the G7 Sous-Sherpa (December 23, 2022)
- [Public Comment Submission] Ministry of Foreign Affairs “Call for Opinions on the Draft Revisions to the Guidelines for the Implementation of the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs)” (November 22, 2023)
- [Urgent Recommendations] The Kidney Disease Control Promotion Project – Establishing Kidney Disease Control Measures with Patient, Citizen, and Community Engagement and Collaboration: Recommendations for Current Issues and Topics in Kidney Disease Control (May 11, 2022)
[Registration Open] Online Public Symposium “Dementia Risk Reduction: How Society Should Face the Individualization of Risk” (December 12, 2023)
[Research Report] Survey of Japanese Physicians Regarding Climate Change and Health (December 3, 2023)
[Registration Open] (Webinar) The 122nd HGPI Seminar: Keeping Pace with Growing Diversity of Health Information in Health Communication (December 19, 2023)
[Policy Recommendations] Recommendation: Suggestions for Building a Resilient and Greener Health Care System Considering Sustainability and Environmental Concerns in the Revision of Medical, Nursing Care, and Disability Welfare Service Fees (December 6, 2023)
[Registration Open] Online Global Expert Meeting: Considering Participation Among People Living with Dementia in the Formulation of National Dementia Strategies and in Policy Making Processes (January 22, 2024)